Dagwood's picture

Hey guys, we've been poking here from time to time to see how the site is evolving, and have noticed that things are progressing.

I think you are aware of a few of the fixes that would be nice from a users perspective, but a bunch of us are going to post here over the course of the day letting you know what we would like to see.

My list is pretty short so far:

  • Less harsh colours - even if its just swapping out the lime green and grey-green so that the lime green is the sidebar, and the grey-green is in the text boxes. That lime-green is very hard on the eyes.
  • More edit buttons - but Kate and I have already experimented with that.
  • Clearer threading - Back in the good old days, before Prospero, the boards were threaded as yours are now, only it was just a title you saw. You clicked the titles to open a message, and the path was clear. Then Prospero came, and it was more difficult to follow threading, but at least you could click the "in reply to" numbers and follow threads back to where they spurred off. I think this iteration of message board technology is less intuitive than either of the others, and much harder to follow.
  • More intuitive HTML tagging. Some of us know a little BB Code, and some HTML, but many of us wish we had buttons that said "bold" "italic" "List" etc. I am trying to use it a little here just to refresh my memory.
  • A spelling checker. I have re-read this before posting. Lets see how many spelling errors I missed.
  • EDIT TO ADD: I forgot Searching can you guys bring back a search engine of some kind that actually looks for words?
  • There have been improvements though since the board was created, and we know you are working to bring them up to a higher standard:

  • We saw our signature lines return. It helps us see who we are talking to!
  • Threading was a negotiated arrangement We saw you working with us to decide whether threads should be sorted in ascending or descending chronological order.
  • Your ongoing commitment to us You have made the promise that you would continue to work with us to create a friendlier environment here.
  • We understand that Taunton has a very high standard in terms of quality, and thta you try to work with the board posters who are some of your most vocal supporters. We hope to continue to work with you to improve and upgrade the website we so much enjoy!

    If it can die, I can kill it.
    Certified Brown Thumb, 4th degree

    bkacker's picture

    Well said, Dagwood. May I (post #15931, reply #1 of 51)

    Well said, Dagwood. May I add, that perhaps instead of 'save' for posting a reply, we have a 'post' button? I'm sure we'd get used to 'save' but at first it's confusing. I haven't even tried posting photos yet. Maybe I will so I can give feedback on that process. Thanks for being our liaison.

    SteveA's picture

    Dagwood, Thanks for the (post #15931, reply #2 of 51)

    Dagwood,

    Thanks for the focused feedback and for not making it personal. It has gotten ugly on some of the other forums (to no one's benefit).

    Kate is working as hard as she can on this. Some of these fixes take time, she has alot of other things to do, and she might get told "no" on some of them.

    I can assure you that you are being heard and that many of your concerns are shared (I still haven't figured out the best way to get around in here, either).

    --Steve Aitken, Editor, Fine Gardening
    the country gardener's picture

    Steve, I'm sorry to hear it's (post #15931, reply #3 of 51)

    Steve,
    I'm sorry to hear it's gotten ugly; you're right, that's to no one's benefit. I am sorry to hear that "no" might be a response, though I understand it. I hope you understand that "no" is going to affect us to an extent, and I was hoping we would all be back eventually. There are still so many aspects of this page that are "greek" to me, and I have to assume to others as well, because there are nowhere near as many non-regulars visiting as before the transition.
    I asked Karen a few questions, which have not as yet all been answered. And I have a few more comments today.
    What on earth does "Filtered words will be replaced with the filtered version of the word" mean?
    I don't have a clue how to translate the HTML stuff into anything meaningful; is it possible to get back the old "I", "U", and "B" buttons? They're a no-brainer for most of us. Having to scroll through a whole thread to find all the new stuff is a pain. On the plus side, I too much prefer that pictures now appear as thumbnails in the text of the message. I note the "Notify me..." box at the bottom; will checking that result in an e-mail at home, a posting in my forum inbox, and will that be for every new post on that thread or just replies to me?
    Again, this isn't all, but enough for one day, and as I said before, I appreciate that you are all trying.

    Marty

    "The plants have been good to us."  Lester Hawkins

    Karen's picture

    "I asked Karen a few (post #15931, reply #4 of 51)

    "I asked Karen a few questions, which have not as yet all been answered."

    ruh roh. can I use Taunton as an excuse at work too?

    On the html thing, I consider myself pretty darn adaptable and on another forum kept a cheat sheet for the few items I decided were worth the trouble, mainly for photo embedding. They actually post tags below the reply box, though I haven't played with them yet. I'll give it a try.

    I'll give it a try.
    I'll give it a try.
    I'll give it a try.
    I'll give it a try.
    I'll give it a try.

    Let's save and see what happens.

    North Carolina - zone 7

    the country gardener's picture

    If you're referring to the (post #15931, reply #5 of 51)

    If you're referring to the "allowed HTML tags, how do you use them?

    Marty

    "The plants have been good to us."  Lester Hawkins

    Karen's picture

    You use them kind of like (post #15931, reply #6 of 51)

    Karen's picture

    Then again, if you string a (post #15931, reply #7 of 51)

    Then again, if you string a whole bunch of them along in series trying to explain it, none of the html tag code-y things show up and all bets are off as to how the formatting ends up.

    North Carolina - zone 7

    debio's picture

    Seriously, it should not be (post #15931, reply #8 of 51)

    Seriously, it should not be that much work!

    Dagwood's picture

    I am replying to Karen's less (post #15931, reply #10 of 51)

    I am replying to Karen's less than Successful attempt at showing how the tags work.

    Lets see how this goes. Replace the square brackets with greater-than and less-than signs in your posts.

    this is format [a] you stop it by typing [/a] and it goes away

    this is format "emphasis" [em] you stop it by typing [/em] and it goes away

    this is format "strong" [strong] you stop it by typing [/strong] and it goes away

    this is format "Citation" [cite] you stop it by typing [/cite] and it goes away

    this is format "Code" [code] you stop it by typing [/code] and it goes away

      this is format "Underline" [ul] you stop it by typing [/ul]

    and it goes away

      this is format "Ordered List" [ol] you stop it by typing [/ol]

    and it goes away

  • this is format "List Item" [li] you stop it by typing [/li]
  • and it goes away

    this is format "Something (???) List" [dl] you stop it by typing [/dl]

    and it goes away

    this is format "Bold" [b] you stop it by typing [/b] and it goes away

    this is format Strikeout [strikeout] you stop it by typing [/strikeout] and it goes away

    Ther eare a lot more codes there to use. If you aren't familiar with them try googling them. You will find primers on how to use the code for different effects.

    If it can die, I can kill it.
    Certified Brown Thumb, 4th degree

    Abbie's picture

    Hi Dagwood, thanks for the (post #15931, reply #15 of 51)

    Hi Dagwood, thanks for the lesson in HTML. I managed to bold and italicize, as you see, but in doing so I didn't put a forward slash in the command to end the feature. I just used the same command again. What purpose does the forward slash serve?

    Northern Virginia, Zone 7A.

    Karen's picture

    Oh yes, I forgot about adding (post #15931, reply #20 of 51)

    Oh yes, I forgot about adding the / to end it. When I did this before I made a document with what I needed for image embedding and just cut and paste from there so I wouldn't have to remember the details.

    It apparently worked, because I didn't remember the details.

    North Carolina - zone 7

    jeana's picture

    Remember the OLDEN days when (post #15931, reply #51 of 51)

    Remember the OLDEN days when that was how we had to change things in a text? You know, back in the 1900's?

    Jeana Never try to baptize a cat.
    Abbie's picture

    ,,,Karen, ,,,let me try the (post #15931, reply #12 of 51)

    ,,,Karen, ,,,let me try the HTML tags because I so agree with Dagwood and Marty; they are difficult to use, particularly if, like me, you have No Clue as to how it's done.

    OK, take a deep breath:

    Northern Virginia, Zone 7A.

    Abbie's picture

    OK, OK, let's try it (post #15931, reply #13 of 51)

    OK, OK, let's try it again...the Italics worked, the strikeout didn't. Now I'll try strikeout and I'll try bold.

    Northern Virginia, Zone 7A.

    Abbie's picture

    OK, how come strikeout (post #15931, reply #14 of 51)

    OK, how come strikeout doesn't work? I'm so excited.

    Northern Virginia, Zone 7A.

    Kate_Frank's picture

    Country Gardener, are you the (post #15931, reply #9 of 51)

    Country Gardener, are you the person I haven't answered? I couldn't remember where to find that comment but I knew someone had asked some questions and hadn't gotten any answers from me. I definitely haven't been deliberately ignoring you!

    the country gardener's picture

    Yup, it was me. I know it's (post #15931, reply #11 of 51)

    Yup, it was me. I know it's not deliberate which I made mention of in the reply yesterday that disappeared.

    Marty

    "The plants have been good to us."  Lester Hawkins

    Kate_Frank's picture

    Let me address these (post #15931, reply #16 of 51)

    Let me address these quickly:

    # Less harsh colours -
    > I'm with you guys on this one, it's important to me, too. This came up in a meeting yesterday.

    # More edit buttons -
    > This is a bug. Every post and every comment should have an edit button. This is slated to be fixed right away.

    # Clearer threading -
    > Improving comments (based on your feedback) will be one of the first things we address after all of Taunton's forums go live and our developers have time to speak with us.

    # More intuitive HTML tagging -
    > I will ask about this, though I don't want to make any promises.

    # A spelling checker -
    > I'll ask about this, too.

    # EDIT TO ADD: I forgot Searching can you guys bring back a search engine of some kind that actually looks for words?
    > The search box should be working now, but we'll be switching to Google to power our search. I'm not sure when this will happen, but Google's the best, so hopefully you'll like it.

    Thanks for recognizing how hard we're working. :)

    ChurchStreetGardner's picture

    Just a couple of comments (post #15931, reply #17 of 51)

    Just a couple of comments that will make the discussion site easier to use - first, float the discussion side bar that is on the left so that as you go down the page the side bar stays in view, second - highlight 'new posts' in some way on the sidebar.

    the country gardener's picture

    Okay, even stranger still, my (post #15931, reply #18 of 51)

    Okay, even stranger still, my post reappeared; it's the one to Steve at 11:32 yesterday. Answers, whenyou get a chance are appreciated. Thanks again, Kate.

    Marty

    "The plants have been good to us."  Lester Hawkins

    Kate_Frank's picture

    On this page? I don't see it. (post #15931, reply #19 of 51)

    On this page? I don't see it.

    the country gardener's picture

    Yes, on this page. On my (post #15931, reply #21 of 51)

    Yes, on this page. On my screen it appears as the fourth post in this topic. It's addressed to Steve and was in reply to his reply to Dagwood.

    Marty

    "The plants have been good to us."  Lester Hawkins

    debio's picture

    Thank you for your work so (post #15931, reply #22 of 51)

    Thank you for your work so far... With that html, I don't mean to sound inflexible, but with all the advances in technology you'd think we wouldn't have to do that! Why doesn't your key board work for that?? I don't "get" that at all. I guess I will just write plain posts, as there is no where else I have to do that on the web. And I use the forums fairly quickly, as I don't spend huge dedicated amounts of time on line. I hop off and on and won't use that system.
    but I do think that figuring out how to make the posts, replies and new messages easier to navigate will be most important.

    Kate_Frank's picture

    I'm going to see if we can (post #15931, reply #25 of 51)

    I'm going to see if we can address this. I know writing HTML is too much for most people.

    Dagwood's picture

    Kate, Does the search bar in (post #15931, reply #23 of 51)

    Kate,

    Does the search bar in the webpage header (across from Taunton) search the forum, or the website? I thought that was there to search the entire site. It is the only Google search I can see.

    If it can die, I can kill it.
    Certified Brown Thumb, 4th degree

    Kate_Frank's picture

    Right now, the search bar (post #15931, reply #24 of 51)

    Right now, the search bar only searches the forums. We'll be moving the whole site over to this new software in the coming months, and then we'll be breaking out the search so you can search them separately. I can't wait till we're using Google for the forums, though. It's so much better than what is currently there.

    Luka's picture

    Kate, I noticed something (post #15931, reply #26 of 51)

    Kate,

    I noticed something that you have done here, that makes navigating a thread, a lot easier.

    You put the avatar at the top of each post.

    One of the biggest complaints from the posters at Breaktime, is that it is difficult to tell where one post leaves off, and another begins.

    I'm going to ask at Breaktime, whether there is any way we could get the avatars with the posts, at Breaktime, too.

    ~~~

    In addition... I posted a tutorial here:, based on work that PatchogPhil did... Explaining an easy way to put borders around each post.

    Do it and forget it. You don't have to keep fiddling with it.

    This also makes it a lot easier to navigate.

    I uploaded the needed css, (style), to the styles site, mentioned in the tutorial thread.

    If you add stylish to your firefox, or other mozilla bvrowser, you can use it's menu to look for styles for this site. It'll take you right to the correct one.

    The entire process is just a few clicks, and a couple of minutes. Nothing complicated. It's more complicated explaining it, than it is doing it.

    ~~~

    Of course... The css could simply be written right into this site, by an admin. Then no one would have to do anything else.

    The needed css is:


    @-moz-document domain(forums.finegardening.com){

    /* Makes message borders visible */

    #comments .comment-published {

    border-color: blue ! important;

    border-style: groove ! important;

    border-width: 2px 2px 2px 2px !important;

    margin:5px !important;

    }

    /* Makes new message borders red */

    #comments .comment-new {

    border-color: red ! important;

    }

    }

    southernsoil's picture

    Thanks Luka. I hope your (post #15931, reply #27 of 51)

    Thanks Luka. I hope your advice is taken.

    debio's picture

    Thanks for the info, but I (post #15931, reply #28 of 51)

    Thanks for the info, but I can't do it! I have a smartphone, which I am working with at home for the time being. It really could/should be done at a higher level.

    Luka's picture

    Agreed. That's why I included (post #15931, reply #29 of 51)

    Agreed.

    That's why I included the css code that could be added to the forum's stylesheets.